Over 1000 Clients Represented
You need an experienced attorney. John has tried more than a dozen cases to jury verdict as lead defense attorney. He knows what a good resolution of your case is, and more importantly what a bad resolution is.
“Mr. Crangle did a great job in handling my legal issue. Quick, polite, easy to work with, and affordable. Definitely would recommend!”
Vincent D“100% recommend John for any ongoing case. He got my case dismissed. Best criminal defense in the upstate.”
Johnathan MWhat Defines Criminal Harassment in South Carolina?
South Carolina law defines harassment under sections 16-3-1700 through 16-3-1750 of the South Carolina Code. There are two levels of criminal harassment, each with distinct criteria.
Harassment in the Second Degree (SC Code § 16-3-1700(B)) involves unwanted behaviors intruding into someone’s private life without a legitimate purpose. These behaviors must cause, or be likely to cause, mental or emotional distress. Actions typically include:
Repeated unwanted phone calls
Continuous texts, emails, or social media messages
Any form of electronic or written communication sustained after a request to stop
Harassment in the First Degree (SC Code § 16-3-1700(A)) is more severe, requiring physical presence or contact. It includes:
Following someone from place to place
Persistent visual or physical contact after being told it’s unwanted
Observing or staying near someone’s home, work, school, or frequent locations
Engaging in activities such as property damage
Both levels require a pattern of behavior. A single incident is typically not enough to constitute harassment. Prosecutors have latitude in how they apply these standards and what constitutes a “pattern.” Understanding these nuances can help in crafting a defense strategy that highlights lack of intent or unreasonable claims.
Additionally, if harassment occurs under a restraining order, the offense is aggravated, potentially increasing both the charge and sentence. This is particularly important if the restraining order stems from prior domestic disputes, as South Carolina courts may view violations in this context with increased severity.
Penalties for Criminal Harassment in Greenville, SC
Penalties are based on whether you’re charged with first or second-degree harassment, and whether you have a criminal record.
Second-Degree Harassment (SC Code § 16-3-1710):
No Prior Record: Misdemeanor with a fine up to $200 and/or up to 30 days in jail.
With Prior Conviction or Under Restraining Order: Misdemeanor with a fine up to $1,000 and/or up to 1 year in jail.
Use of Motor Vehicle Information: An additional fine of $200 and/or 30 days in jail.
First-Degree Harassment (SC Code § 16-3-1720):
No Prior Record: Misdemeanor with a fine up to $1,000 and/or up to 3 years in prison.
Under Restraining Order: Misdemeanor with a fine up to $2,000 and/or up to 3 years in prison.
Past Conviction for Harassment/Stalking: Felony with a fine up to $5,000 and/or up to 5 years in prison.
Use of Motor Vehicle Data: Additional fine of $1,000 and/or 1 year in prison.
Previous convictions significantly impact potential outcomes. A second offense involving the same victim within ten years can elevate charges from misdemeanor to felony. Additionally, the use of motor vehicle data in harassment, reflecting the state’s emphasis on protecting personal privacy, can result in enhanced penalties.
It’s important to distinguish between harassment and stalking, the latter often involving intent to cause fear of harm. Stalking carries different, sometimes stricter, penalties.
How Harassment Cases Are Handled in Greenville County
Harassment cases usually begin with a complaint to law enforcement or a magistrate. Magistrates can issue warrants, and the case then navigates through the criminal process. First-degree harassment, given its severity, can even reach General Sessions Court.
Prosecutors rely on text messages, call logs, social media records, security footage, and witness testimony. Establishing a “pattern” is critical, requiring more than one or two incidents linked as part of a “course of conduct.” The thoroughness of evidence gathering in South Carolina is a key factor in prosecution, and any gaps can be leveraged for defense.
A restraining order greatly aids the prosecution; any violation becomes a clear disregard of a judicial order. Magistrates can issue temporary orders if there’s immediate danger, which constitutes a criminal offense and contempt of court if violated.
Harassment might be linked to domestic issues, protective order breaches, or workplace conflicts. It’s not limited to romantic contexts. South Carolina law mandates that all relevant evidence be gathered meticulously to ensure a fair trial and just outcome. Judges in Greenville County often encourage mediation or counseling sessions as part of probationary terms, especially for first-time offenders, to address underlying issues and reduce recidivism. This approach reflects a community-oriented perspective in handling personal disputes.
Defense Strategies Against Criminal Harassment
Question the Pattern: For harassment, a pattern is essential. If incidents are isolated or arose from legitimate contexts, argue against the pattern requirement.
Challenge Intent: The behavior must be intentional and unreasonable. Situations involving legitimate reasons, such as child custody or business disputes, may not meet the threshold for harassment.
Doubt Emotional Impact: The state needs to prove the conduct could cause a reasonable person’s distress. If the victim’s distress seems exaggerated or inconsistent, it can undermine this element. Demonstrating that the alleged victim did not exhibit distress at the time can be pivotal.
First Amendment Issues: Not all unwelcome contact is illegal. Offensive yet purely verbal communications can involve free speech rights if not crossing into threats or other illegal territory.
Defense against False Claims: Accusations can arise from personal disputes where the accuser has motives to exaggerate. Highlight any biases or motives to lie. This is crucial, especially in cases where a prior personal relationship exists.
Contextual Communication: Required communication in co-parenting or business matters differs from harassment. Be prepared to argue these distinctions.
If harassment charges connect with incidents like fleeing police or juvenile crimes, these broader issues must also be addressed. If unavoidable, explore opportunities for expungement in the future. Understanding the interplay between different charges can help in crafting a comprehensive defense strategy.
Why a Lawyer Is Essential for Harassment Charges in Greenville
A collateral consequence often overlooked in harassment cases is the impact on professional licensing. If you hold a license in healthcare, law, education, finance, or real estate, a harassment conviction, even a misdemeanor, can trigger a mandatory disclosure to your licensing board. South Carolina professional boards treat crimes involving repeated unwanted contact seriously, and some boards have discretion to suspend or revoke a license when a licensee is convicted of any crime involving dishonesty or harassment of another person.
Harassment charges evolve quickly in South Carolina. A misdemeanor becomes far more severe if any prior contact with the judicial system involving the same individual exists. A felony conviction has lasting implications, affecting job prospects, housing, and community reputation.
It’s best to address these charges early, preferably before the prosecution builds its case, before the alleged victim solidifies their story, and before the hearings make the positions more inflexible. A Greenville attorney will understand local approaches and scrutinize the state’s evidence from day one. Local knowledge of how Greenville County courts handle such cases can be an invaluable asset in your defense.
If an issued restraining order exists, two parallel cases arise: one for the contempt or criminal violation and the underlying harassment charge. Coordinated management of both is crucial. The complexity of handling these cases concurrently underscores the need for experienced legal counsel.
John Crangle, a criminal defense attorney in Greenville, handles harassment and stalking cases within the 13th Judicial Circuit. He assesses evidence, proposes defenses, and supports you from initial hearings to trial.
Contact John Crangle today for a consultation. Time is critical with harassment allegations, so prompt legal support is vital.