Over 1000 Clients Represented
You need an experienced attorney. John has tried more than a dozen cases to jury verdict as lead defense attorney. He knows what a good resolution of your case is, and more importantly what a bad resolution is.
“Mr. Crangle did a great job in handling my legal issue. Quick, polite, easy to work with, and affordable. Definitely would recommend!”
Vincent D“100% recommend John for any ongoing case. He got my case dismissed. Best criminal defense in the upstate.”
Johnathan MUnderstanding Insurance Fraud in South Carolina
In South Carolina, insurance fraud is addressed through various statutes. The primary legal provisions can be found in S.C. Code § 38-55-170, concerning presenting false claims for payment, and S.C. Code § 38-55-540, which details the criminal penalties under the Omnibus Insurance Fraud and Reporting Immunity Act.
According to § 38-55-170, it is illegal to knowingly cause a false claim to be presented to an insurer, health maintenance organization, or any person providing health care benefits. This law applies to both those submitting the claim and anyone who assists, solicits, or conspires with them.
Section § 38-55-540 expands this scope, targeting any knowing false statement or misrepresentation made with intent to defraud, deceive, or injure in connection with any insurance transaction. This can include staging accidents, padding claims, misrepresenting injuries or damage, filing for non-existent events, or submitting false medical documentation.
The statute covers anyone involved, including attorneys, medical professionals, and others who partake in fraudulent schemes, even if they do not file the claim themselves.
Common insurance fraud cases in South Carolina involve staged car accidents, inflated property damage claims, fraudulent medical billing, workers’ compensation fraud, arson-for-insurance schemes, and life insurance fraud. With the increase of staged accident schemes, new laws are actively being considered to specifically address staged motor vehicle collisions as a distinct felony. South Carolina’s approach is deterrent-focused, emphasizing prevention through stringent legal measures.
Penalties for Insurance Fraud in Greenville
The penalties for insurance fraud in South Carolina vary based on the economic gain from the fraud.
For a first-offense misdemeanor involving less than $1,000, fines range from $100 to $500, with possible jail time of up to 30 days. For benefits between $1,000 and $10,000, the first offense remains a misdemeanor, but with higher fines from $2,000 to $10,000 and imprisonment of up to three years.
A first-offense felony occurs when the gain is between $10,000 and $50,000, carrying fines from $10,000 to $50,000 and a maximum of five years in prison. When the amount exceeds $50,000, first-offense felonies involve fines between $20,000 and $100,000 with imprisonment up to ten years.
For subsequent violations, any amount results in felony charges, with fines ranging from $20,000 to $100,000 and up to ten years in prison.
False claims under § 38-55-170 also result in felonies, with penalties of up to ten years in prison or fines up to $5,000 when the claim is $10,000 or more. Claims between $2,000 and $10,000 can lead to five years in prison, with misdemeanors applicable below $2,000.
Besides criminal penalties, individuals convicted must provide full restitution to the victims. Civil penalties up to $5,000 for a first offense, $10,000 for a second, and $15,000 for further offenses may accompany these criminal penalties. The state emphasizes restitution to ensure victims are compensated for their losses.
Prosecuting Insurance Fraud in Greenville County
Insurance fraud investigations in South Carolina are conducted by SLED under the state’s Insurance Fraud Division within the Attorney General’s Office. Local law enforcement, including the Greenville County Sheriff’s Office, may also handle specific cases like staged accidents or arson-for-insurance schemes.
When fraud is suspected, insurers are required to report it to the Insurance Fraud Division under § 38-55-570. Insurers often possess substantial documentation before criminal investigators step in, as they employ Special Investigations Units (SIUs) to identify suspicious claims.
Cases prosecuted in the 13th Judicial Circuit include various types of insurance fraud, from healthcare fraud and vehicle accident staging to property claims fraud and workers’ compensation fraud, handled in Greenville County’s General Sessions Court. The Solicitor’s Office and the Attorney General’s Insurance Fraud Division work together on more complex cases.
Federal prosecution may occur in cases involving Medicare or Medicaid fraud, schemes impacting federally regulated insurers, or those involving wire communications and interstate fraud statutes. Such cases are prosecuted in the United States District Court for the District of South Carolina.
Insurance fraud indictments may include related charges. Forgery / Counterfeiting may arise when false documentation supports a claim. Fraud by False Pretenses could also be added. In complex cases, Money Laundering charges follow when proceeds are moved and concealed. The interconnected nature of these charges often complicates the defense process.
Defense Strategies for Insurance Fraud
Defending against insurance fraud charges involves challenging both the factual base of the allegation and the legal elements the prosecution must prove.
The prosecution needs to prove you knowingly made a false statement or claim. If you believed in good faith that your claim was accurate, those losses were genuine, or the documents submitted were correct, the intent element isn’t met. A genuine belief, even if unreasonable, can negate criminal liability.
Challenging the damage calculation is crucial since the amount determines whether you face misdemeanor or felony charges. If the prosecution overstates the economic gain, proving the actual lesser amount can reduce the severity of charges.
In cases involving accidents, property damage, or medical claims, disputing the causal chain can be effective. If the losses were genuine despite imperfect documentation, the conduct might not legally qualify as fraud. The prosecution must prove the statement was false, not merely that the documentation was flawed.
Challenging investigative procedures may result in suppressing key evidence. While insurance company investigators aren’t bound by constitutional rules like law enforcement, SLED and other government agencies are, so Fourth and Fifth Amendment protections apply.
In multi-defendant cases, disputing your specific role in the fraud can limit your exposure, especially if your knowledge of the broader conspiracy was minimal. The strategy often involves highlighting discrepancies in the alleged fraud’s execution.
The Importance of Legal Representation for Insurance Fraud
South Carolina prosecutes insurance fraud aggressively, with a distinct division for it. Insurers conduct their investigations. Potential penalties range from thousands to hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines, along with prison time.
A fraud conviction shares the same collateral consequences as other felony frauds: loss of professional licenses, difficulty finding employment and housing, federal firearm restrictions, and a lifelong criminal record.
The technical complexity of insurance fraud prosecutions involves scrutinizing medical records, accident reconstructions, actuarial analyses, and financial document tracing, demanding a defense attorney who is adept with this type of evidence.
John Crangle, a Greenville Criminal Defense Lawyer, defends clients facing insurance fraud and related White Collar Crimes charges in Greenville County and the 13th Judicial Circuit. He understands both the state prosecution structure and the relevant federal rules applicable in healthcare and federally regulated insurance.
If you’re also contending with allegations of Embezzlement or Credit Card Fraud, these charges can be addressed through a unified defense strategy.
Contact John Crangle for a private consultation on your insurance fraud charges in Greenville.